( 19% )
E-Mail
Print
WASHINGTON (AP) -- The Supreme Court ruling on President Barack Obama's health care overhaul, now just hours away, marks a key pivot point in the presidential race. But neither side knows which direction the high court's decision will turn the contest.
"My guess is they're not sleeping real well at the White House tonight," presumptive Republican presidential nominee Mitt Romney told supporters Wednesday in northern Virginia.
Anticipation of Thursday's decision could be equally unnerving for Romney, whose opposition to the law has become a central pillar of his campaign.
COMPLETE WBEN COVERAGE: New York Ready, But States Not United | Is Debate About Politics? | Health Care Ruling Hangs Over Elections, Congress | Romney, Obama Ready For Ruling | On The WBEN Liveline & In Studio, In-Depth | The Four Big Questions The Court Must Decide
|
Buffalo, NY (WBEN) As the debate over the health care reform law comes to a head with Thursday's Supreme Court decision, some are wondering if the debate was more politics or about health care. One local political strategist says it was a mix of both. "It's driven by the policy issue of health care, and how best to provide it and pay for it," says former Deputy Erie County Executive Carl Calabrese. "But then we have two parties, each with its own perspective, and you have the political debate. That's the way the system works, and you carve out a position, get it passed and it becomes law, but that's not how this ended." Calabrese adds the law was passed while both houses of Congress were controlled by Democrats. "Had there been more attempt to reach out by the Obama administration to Republicans, there likely could have been a compromise crafted that would have had more of a consensus vote," explains Calabrese. He also says polls show a majority don't like it, and the Democrats' strategy of let the people see it and they'll like it hasn't come to fruition. "Anywhere from 55 to 60 percent of people want to see this killed. This is so flawed they want to see this go back to the drawing board and start all over," notes Calabrese. He says there is a series of legal issues over the constitutionality of the law, especially with regards to the individual mandate for health insurance coverage. "The fact we may be on the verge of giving government the power to order people to buy something they don't want to buy has incredible ramifications on what kind of country we are. If the court rules in favor of the law, where does that stop?" ponders Calabrese. |
Neither candidate has any direct influence over the ruling. The court could uphold the health care law, strike it down or deem the requirement that most Americans carry health insurance unconstitutional while retaining other aspects of the law.
The announcement is expected to be followed almost immediately by a barrage of advertisements and fundraising appeals from Democrats and Republicans, all trying to cast the decision in the most advantageous light for their candidates.
Secrecy has marked each campaign's planning for the critical moment.
Obama will be in Washington and is expected to respond, but his specific plans to do so were unclear. Romney's campaign has refused to disclose the location of a Capitol Hill venue where he will face reporters shortly after the announcement.
It is clear, however, that the Supreme Court's ruling on Obama's sweeping federal health care law will shape the contours of the presidential campaign through the summer and fall. Both Obama and his Republican rival are primed to use the outcome - whatever it is - for political gain.
Obama has expressed confidence the court will uphold his signature legislative initiative. But he won't be shocked if a conservative majority overturns the most controversial provision, those familiar with his thinking say. Romney aides say the Republican candidate will get a political boost if the court strikes down the measure. But they don't want celebrations that could alienate voters who could lose health care benefits through the decision.
The court's ruling could have a far-reaching impact on the nation's health care system. If the law is upheld, about 30 million of the 50 million uninsured Americans would get coverage in 2014 when a big expansion begins.
Overturning all or part of the law could leave as uninsured the more than 3 million young adults who gained coverage through a provision allowing them to stay on their parents' insurance up to age 26, according to the Health and Human Services Department. Another 60,000 people who gained coverage through a plan for those with pre-existing conditions may not be able to get coverage elsewhere if the entire law is struck down.
Obama recently has avoided mentioning the impending court ruling directly, but he has vigorously defended the health care overhaul as critical to the public's health and well-being in campaign events this week.
"I think it was the right thing to do. I know it was the right thing to do," he told supporters in Boston.
Romney, who as Massachusetts governor signed a health care law on which the Obama's federal law was modeled, has focused more than usual on the Supreme Court ruling this week. In campaign appearances in Virginia, New Jersey and New York, he offered supporters and donors a preview of his likely response to the decision and said Obama's first term would be essentially wasted if the law is overturned.
If the court upholds the law, Romney told supporters at a northern Virginia electronics manufacturer Wednesday, it's still bad policy. "And that'll mean if I'm elected president we're going to repeal it and replace it," he said.
And if the court strikes down the law, Romney said, "They're going to be doing some of my work for me. "
Obama advisers say the Supreme Court showed reasonableness earlier this week in a ruling on an Arizona immigration case, and they see it as a hopeful sign for how the court might rule on health care.
If the court upholds the law, Obama could get an election-year gust of wind at his back, with his vision and leadership validated. If the court strikes down the overhaul, the White House would seek to cast the decision as detrimental to millions of Americans by highlighting popular elements of the law that would disappear, such as preventive care and coverage for young adults on parents' plans.
The Romney campaign has coordinated its response directly with the Republican National Committee and House Republicans, who have agreed not to "spike the ball" - as one Republican put it - should the law be struck down. His campaign worries that an over-celebratory tone may turn off voters affected by the decision.
Indeed, the stakes are high for both candidates. Polling suggests that most Americans oppose the law, but an overwhelming majority want Congress and the president to find a new remedy if it's struck down.
Romney so far has spent little time crafting a comprehensive plan to replace the overhaul. And the Obama campaign already has seized on Romney's opposition to the most popular provisions in the law. For example, Romney would not prevent health care companies from denying coverage to new customers with medical conditions. Nor would he force them to cover young adults on their parents' plans through age 26.
Still, both sides will use it to raise money and motivate supporters. The Democratic Congressional Campaign Committee issued a fundraising appeal for a "health care rapid response fund," telling supporters in an email Wednesday that however the court rules, "Democrats are in for a tough fight."
