"This is a long-term battle that everyone's going to watch. Other teachers unions in the United States are wondering if they should follow suit." - Eric Hanuskek, a senior fellow in education at the Hoover Institution of Stanford University , after Chicago teachers walked out of the classroom Monday, taking a bitter contract dispute over evaluations and job security.
Do Strikes Work? Expert Says Seldom, But WNY Scorecard is Mixed....
Art Wheaton, a labor education expert in the Buffalo extension office of Cornell's NYS Labor Relations School says while striking workers often feel a walkout is their only option, they seldom win by striking.
"I think it's always bad for any union to go on strike unless you are absolutely desperate. You can't predict what will happen, " he says.
Locally, in the past year, CWA workers at Verizon and Teamsters at Sorrento Cheese's South Buffalo plant both struck.
In the Verizon case, they came back without a contract and still need to get one months later. At Sorrento however, workers preserved health benefits and jobs in a short July strike.
"We've seen mixed results for what happens when people attempt to go out on strike. Usually who wins is the competition," Wheaton says.
The unions are taking a major stand on teacher evaluations, one of the key issues in the Chicago dispute. If they lose there, it could have ripple effects around the country.
Exclusive WBEN Audio
On The WBEN Liveline
WGN Reporter Brandon Campbell in Chicago
and after briefly discussing 9/11
Dave Levinthal, Politico.com
Members of the Chicago Teachers Union — the AFT’s oldest local — walked off the job Monday for the first time in 25 years over issues that include pay raises, classroom conditions, job security and teacher evaluations.
They are pitted against Chicago Mayor Rahm Emanuel, a powerful Democrat — and former chief of staff to President Barack Obama — who wants to extract more concessions from teachers while the school district faces a nearly $700 million deficit.
Major teacher strikes have been rare in recent years, compared with the 1960s and 1970s, when teachers went on strike frequently for better pay and improved bargaining rights. While unions generally got what they wanted in the past, they face a tougher climate today.
Issues in the Chicago teacher strike; health benefits, teacher evaluations, job security sound strikingly similar to ones raised with far less urgency in Buffalo in recent years and even weeks.
"It's terrible. It's Terrible. But sometimes you have no choice," Rumore says adding that no one wins in a strike " It's the last resort but sometimes when your back is against the wall, you have no choice."
With the weak economy, unions have seen massive teacher layoffs, increased class sizes and school districts unable or unwilling to boost teacher salaries. Like other public employee unions, they are also under attack from Republican governors like Scott Walker of Wisconsin, who signed a measure last year to curb collective bargaining rights and limit benefits for state workers.
The 2.2-million member NEA has lost more than 100,000 members since 2010, as fewer public school teachers are hired and more charter schools open, most of which are not unionized. At the 1.5 million-member AFT, years of steady growth have leveled off.
‘‘They certainly are on the defensive,’’ said Richard Ingersoll, a professor of education and sociology at the University of Pennsylvania. ‘‘They are under attack. A lot of times they are demonized. On the other hand there’s really smart and progressive elements in the teacher’s movement who want to get out ahead of this and do it in a way that’s fair.’’
In the past, teachers unions could count on a Democratic White House to fight back on their behalf. But Obama’s education secretary, Arne Duncan, is a former head of Chicago Public Schools who has pushed for many of the changes that unions oppose.
‘‘In many ways the Obama administration has signed onto the very conservative set of reforms that the education community is imposing on teachers,’’ said Richard Kahlenberg of the Century Foundation, a nonpartisan think tank in Washington.
Both the NEA and the AFT have strongly endorsed Obama’s re-election despite his administration’s support of policies to expand charter schools, weaken tenure and base teacher evaluations on how much student performance improves.
The Chicago union argues that the new teacher evaluation system relies too heavily on standardized test scores without considering outside factors such as student poverty, violence and homelessness that can affect performance.
Hess said the Chicago strike has become an important test case after unions lost their effort to recall Wisconsin’s governor.
‘‘If it looks like the union folds, especially on the heels of Wisconsin, it’s a huge blow for the unions,’’ Hess said. ‘‘If the union seems to win, that’s going to be a blow to reform-minded mayors and puts some wind into the sails of unions.’’
There are major differences, though, between the cases in Wisconsin and Chicago.
While Walker effectively challenged public employee unions’ collective bargaining rights, both sides in Chicago have been negotiating over traditional labor-management issues. The district proposed a 16 percent raise over four years and the two sides have essentially agreed on a longer school day. But job security and a new teacher evaluation system remained in dispute.
‘‘This is a long-term battle that everyone’s going to watch,’’ said Eric Hanuskek, a senior fellow in education at the Hoover Institution of Stanford University. ‘‘Other teachers unions in the United States are wondering if they should follow suit.’’
Teacher unions also are growing nervous about how they are portrayed in an upcoming Hollywood movie called ‘‘Won’t Back Down,’’ set to open in theaters on Sept. 28. The film tells the story of a mother’s quest to take control of her daughter’s failing elementary school.
AFT President Randi Weingarten has blasted the movie as ‘‘using the most blatant stereotypes and caricatures I have ever seen’’ and unfairly blaming unions for the nation’s school woes. Union leaders were even more outraged that the movie was screened at the Democratic National Convention in Charlotte, N.C., and that Los Angeles Mayor Antonio Villaraigosa — the convention chairman — attended the screening.
Villaraigosa is a former union organizer who has spoken out in favor of greater accountability for schools and teachers.